No internet connection
  1. Home
  2. Support

"Reply" vs "Comment" label on button in the comments UI

By Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-28 18:54:27.480Z2019-05-29 00:40:29.499Z

The original concern turned out to be a misunderstanding
of the meaning of the main "Reply" button in the page
comments UI.

Original posting:

I am trying out Talkyard with my Hugo site, and testing locally.
I have added http://localhost:1313 to the list of sites in my
admin area and have set up my pages to show Talkyard comments.

Snippet result:

<script async defer src=""></script>
<div class="talkyard-comments" data-discussion-id="" style="margin-top: 45px;">
<noscript>Please enable Javascript to view comments.</noscript>
<p style="margin-top: 25px; opacity: 0.9; font-size: 96%">Comments powered by
<a href="">Talkyard</a>.</p>

I have also tried a snippet with a non-empty discussionId,
same visible result.

When I go to a page I see a display of Talkyard information.


I see no place to enter a comment, but there is a button to allow me to
reply to the nonexistent comment.

How can I fix this?


  • 9 replies
  1. KajMagnus @KajMagnus2019-05-28 19:03:08.652Z

    Hi Cris, the reply button is for replying to the blog post that is supposed to be visible above the reply button. If you have a look at the comments section here:
    you'll see the same reply button, and a similar "NNN replies" horizontal bar. This time, though, there's a blog post above the Reply button. Maybe this makes it more clear how everything is supposed to work?

    Or am I missing something :- ) Maybe you'd like to post a screenshot of your whole page? Is there something above the reply button, in your case?

    if you click Reply, then, an editor should appear so you can type a comment. Currently, there's no always-visible editor (although I'm startnig to think that'd be a nice thing to have).

    1. Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-28 19:14:06.521Z


      Thanks for the very prompt response.

      I understood the "reply" button as a way to reply to another comment.
      My plan is to provide for comments, actually more likely questions
      about information on the web site, not a blog post.

      So I was expecting a small always-visible editor and a button
      that says something more like "Comment" or perhaps "Ask question"
      or "Question / comment".

      As you can tell, my first thought or three is that "reply" is confusing
      in this context.

      1. KajMagnus @KajMagnus2019-05-28 19:35:41.382Z

        (Sometimes it takes a day or more before I reply o. O   it's a bit random)

        I could edit the main Reply button title to "Ask a question", via custom CSS. Let me know.

        (Adding an always visible editor, that's relatively much work though, won't happen the nearest time.)

        ( Custom CSS. Something like this seems to work:

        .dw-ar-t > .esPA .icon-reply b {
            display: none;  /* remove "Reply"  .... */
        .dw-ar-t > .esPA .icon-reply::after {
            content: 'Ask a question';  /* ... and add this */
            opacity: 1;
            font-size: 15px;
            font-weight: bold;
            white-space: nowrap;


        1. Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-28 22:08:23.347Z

          Yes, that makes sense, thanks. I had been thinking maybe I could do something of the kind.

          I like a lot about your approach, both from the point of view of features and also client/provider relationships (especially that there is open source). Since your reply I have gone on to playing around with what I can do with comments on my test site. Talkyard is surprisingly powerful in a few different dimensions.


          1. Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-29 00:37:10.236Z

            Unfortunately the comments display is in an iframe, and I don't
            know how to affect the styling of content in an iframe,
            especially as it is cross-site. I can modify the CSS through
            the Chrome DOM inspector, but not through a CSS file.

            Any thoughts on that?

            1. KajMagnus @KajMagnus2019-05-29 02:47:39.490Z

              There's a CSS editor here:

              (Hmm maybe I can make it easier to find somehow.)

              1. Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-29 22:29:02.218Z2019-06-04 11:48:01.253Z

                Whoah, I didn't see that one coming. Yes, your CSS works, and I have done a little more customizing, though I can't promise all of it is wise. But I prefer to start with a fairly minimalist UI for the inexperienced user.

                For what it's worth, here is my current CSS. I have hidden the main Talkyard toolbar header and removed editing of comments.

                Thanks much.

                .dw-ar-t > .esPA .icon-reply b {
                    display: none;  /* remove "Reply"  .... */
                .dw-ar-t > .esPA .icon-reply::after {
                    content: 'Comment';  /* ... and add this */
                    opacity: 1;
                    font-size: 15px;
                    font-weight: bold;
                    white-space: nowrap;
                /* Don't show the biggish block toolbar */
                .dw-cmts-tlbr-head {
                    display: none;
                /* Don't support editing comments. */
                a.dw-a.dw-a-edit.icon-edit {
                    display: none;
            2. In reply toCrisP:
              KajMagnus @KajMagnus2019-05-29 02:48:31.469Z

              If you have time, I'm wondering which dimensions you have in mind? Maybe there's something could mention on the homepage (so others find out sooner)

              1. Cris Perdue @CrisP2019-05-29 22:25:30.453Z

                That is not such an easy question. I was just looking for something fairly minimal with modest cost structure for a site doesn't aim for a whole lot of traffic. I was trying, which is cute, but probably a bit too minimalist and requires GitHub login, which seemed a little doubtful.

                The capabilities of Talkyard seem to kind of go on and on. Tons of room for growth if desired, for example forums. Customizable via CSS, as I am now aware. ;-)

      2. Progress
        with handling this problem
      3. @KajMagnus marked this topic as Done 2019-06-09 12:29:40.899Z.